Separation to community board and center board

[Ivan Denisov]

So checking a forum daily just to find out that there is nothing new is
a waste of time and would keep me away from this forum.

Josef, you can subscribe for "center" forums.

subscribe.png (42.35 KiB) Viewed 14062 times

Usenet for me is something strange from the past, like console interface for Doug
But if others also think that it can helps, I will learn this technology.

[cfbsoftware]

This must be a misunderstanding.

I don't think so. I was responding to Doug's comment saying he preferred to be emailed directly with the latest comments. I don't think he was talking about UseNet.

You are not interrupted in any way by using a usenent news reader.

I am very familiar with the capabilities of UseNet as I used it regularly from the early 1990's until a few years ago. Unfortunately my ISP stopped supporting the feeds and I can only access it now via Google Groups which is not nearly as useful as using dedicated newsreader software. (No - I have no intention of changing my ISP).

[ReneK]

As I see this, the vote would currently look like this:

*) We should separate the center member boards from the other non-center boards, with the center boards administered by OberonCore
*) We should put all discussions on the non-center boards to a halt until the center is established
*) We should move the non-center boards to Usenet or Google Groups
*) We should move the center boards to Usenet or Google Groups
*) We should keep the boards as they are
*) I'm fine with all options mentioned
*) I abstain from this vote

We haven't had any new options come up in the last days.

The following members have expressed that they are ready for a vote, or have a proposal, or have shown support for a proposal for this vote:
OberonCore
ReneK
IvanD
CFB Software
DGDanforth
Josef Templ

If I interprete this correctly, we still need
Ivan K,
Peter Kushnir,
Robert Campbell
Gary Warner
to voice their opinion or their readiness for a vote to go on.

I just contacted our four "missing" colleagues in order to speed things up.

[Josef Templ]

I would replace boards by forums as we have only one board but multiple forums.

The set of choices is not complete because there are multiple independent issues and not all combinations are covered.
1. if there is a split, transfer center forums to oberoncore, to usenet, leave them
2. if there is a split, transfer community forums to usenet
3. suspend all community forums until center is established
These issues are independent, so may be the vote should be split.

Add an explanation what a particular choice would mean and which problem it solves.
What is the advantage of center management by oberoncore, for example?
I don't want to express any preference here but I want to understand the reasons and implications.

[ReneK]

Good ideas, Josef.

Add an explanation what a particular choice would mean and which problem it solves.

I thought that the discussion of what each choice means is what this thread here is all about. I assumed that everybody who either paricipated in the discussion or told us that there is enough discussion and we should now vote, basically had read the thread and therefore is informed about what each proposal means.

What is the advantage of center management by oberoncore, for example?

I think that OberonCore started this discussion with a problem they think needs solving.
Everyone who proposed an option, also wrote what he thinks the advantages are.
To some of those proposals, others answered what they think the disadvantages are.

Do you mean that the vote should include a synopsis of the discussion? I wouldn't like that as I fear that if I write the synopsis, it would probably not be impartial, and thus I would influence the votes. And I think it is unnecessary, because everyone voting should just read the thread.

[warnersoft]

I'm in favor of separating the general discussions to a format similar to the component pascal group on yahoo, in which i receive one consolidated email each day with all the discussions. Certainly the "center" needs to be able to vote, if that means staying on this forum, so be it, although it would be nice to get a consolidated email with the discussions rather than having to sign on and find out what's going on.

[ReneK]

I'm in favor of separating the general discussions to a format similar to the component pascal group on yahoo, in which i receive one consolidated email each day with all the discussions. Certainly the "center" needs to be able to vote, if that means staying on this forum, so be it, although it would be nice to get a consolidated email with the discussions rather than having to sign on and find out what's going on.

It seems that this feature is available for phpbb, the software currently used by both blackboxframework.org and oberoncore.ru:

https://phpbbservices.com/digests_wp/

Please check, if this does the trick for you.

If so, OberonCore and Ivan D., do you know if your boards are set up to deal with this, or would it be possible for you to install/activate what is needed to do this?

If so, those who want a digest and/or eMail of all new posts, get that by choosing one of the following options

*) We should separate the center member forums from the other non-center forums, with the center forums administered by OberonCore
*) We should put all discussions on the non-center forums to a halt until the center is established
*) We should move the center forums to Usenet or Google Groups [depends on if you wish to retain the voting ability of the board, but there is also a voting mechanism on Google]

[ReneK]

I would replace boards by forums
These issues are independent, so may be the vote should be split.

How would you split? How would you formulate the votes? Also please keep in mind that there are options which are currently not "available" since there is no one who volunteered to do the work (eg. the option "Rene administrates the center board on a machine different from Oberore's and Ivan's" is not covered, because I do not volunteer for that.)

Rene

[Ivan Denisov]

If so, OberonCore and Ivan D., do you know if your boards are set up to deal with this, or would it be possible for you to install/activate what is needed to do this?

I have no experience with that feature. If "center" will vote I will install it. I do not want to make demo for this feature.

[ReneK]

If so, OberonCore and Ivan D., do you know if your boards are set up to deal with this, or would it be possible for you to install/activate what is needed to do this?

I have no experience with that feature. If "center" will vote I will install it. I do not want to make demo for this feature.

Ivan, I do not break my own rules. I do not ask for doing things without vote. I just wanted to know if it is possible to be done or not.