Do we need Wiki like MediaWiki? Should id be opened to every member or only for "center" members?
Please, discuss it here and vote. The opinion can be changed in this poll. Lets make an experiment and unite the discussion and voting in one thread?
Official status of Wiki
-
Ivan Denisov
- Posts: 1700
- Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 12:21 am
- Location: Russia
Re: Official status of Wiki
This is a misrepresentation.
I do not reject a wiki, but I question the need for a wiki right now. And since you added the Wiki without any authority to do so, I asked you to remove it again, until any decision is made.
So, the question is not: "Do we need a Wiki" or "will we ever need a wiki", but rather the following:
"Do we want a wiki now, and what for?"
"Do we want a wiki as a repository for the center white paper in discussion?"
"To operate a wiki for the organisational needs we have, what do we need, and can we provide this right now?" (this is an organisational question, not a technical!)
"What do we as a center need right now, and what tool is best suited?"
To make this a question of "Do we want a wiki" is misleading false. Do you mislead because you did not understand, or was it intentional?
And of course you again open a vote without prior discussion.
I do not reject a wiki, but I question the need for a wiki right now. And since you added the Wiki without any authority to do so, I asked you to remove it again, until any decision is made.
So, the question is not: "Do we need a Wiki" or "will we ever need a wiki", but rather the following:
"Do we want a wiki now, and what for?"
"Do we want a wiki as a repository for the center white paper in discussion?"
"To operate a wiki for the organisational needs we have, what do we need, and can we provide this right now?" (this is an organisational question, not a technical!)
"What do we as a center need right now, and what tool is best suited?"
To make this a question of "Do we want a wiki" is misleading false. Do you mislead because you did not understand, or was it intentional?
And of course you again open a vote without prior discussion.
Last edited by ReneK on Fri Oct 18, 2013 5:46 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
Ivan Denisov
- Posts: 1700
- Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2013 12:21 am
- Location: Russia
Re: Official status of Wiki
Please, look at my post carefully! This is discussion and voting in one thread. The Vote is only the poll in top message. And bellow the discussion. I made the poll infinite time to monitor people opinion. Please, answer your questions here if you wants. For me and I am sure for most members answers are clear and they are able to choose.ReneK wrote:And of course you again open a vote without prior discussion.